It’s graduation time in America. And if recent years are any indication, several of our nation’s top scholars will take to the podiums during commencement exercises and shock the assemblage by declaring that they aren’t U.S. citizens, or even legal residents. Such declarations, and their frequency, are clear proof that the lack of legal status, for which they are not at fault, doesn’t affect their achievement, their value as students, or their right to pursue their dreams of success in the only land they know.

Strangely, despite the obvious intelligence, abilities and potential of these top students, efforts continue to delegitimize them and have them summarily thrown out of this country.

Fortunately, reason continues to win out.

The 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday struck down the Trump administration’s efforts to end protections for U.S. immigrants who were brought here as children and have lived here their entire lives.

In its majority ruling, a three-judge panel ruled that the current administration was “arbitrary and capricious” in its efforts to kill Barack Obama’s Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals without giving good reason, or saying what would happen to them.

This is only the latest such ruling. Circuit Court decisions apply only to their respective regions of jurisdiction, but several other federal courts have ruled the same way.

Each ruling only adds to the pile of reasons that Congress members should step up their efforts to pass legislation that would settle the issue once and for all.

Even if the House and Senate don’t have enough votes to override President Trump’s inevitable veto, the bill would issue a statement from the many representatives of our nation’s people that this matter isn’t going away.

Previous efforts to pass the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act have fallen short; it was most recently offered in 2017, but Republican opposition in both houses kept the bill from advancing.

The current Democratic Party majority in the House should be able to move it along, at least in that chamber.

The issue affects an estimated 800,000 young people, and many of them are our neighbors in the Rio Grande Valley. They were raised as Americans and their places of birth are as foreign to them as they are to most U.S. citizens. They literally would have no place to go in any country to which they would be deported.

We must remember too that improper deportations wouldn’t affect just the Dreamers, but also the families that would be torn apart and the communities that would lose their talents and contributions if they were to be kicked out of this country.

Even current Trump Energy Secretary Rick Perry, as Texas governor, recognized that residency trumps nationality when he advocated for allowing Texas Dreamers to pay in-state tuition at the state’s universities.

With so much at stake close to home, Valley and Texas lawmakers should lead the charge in pushing this legislation forward. It undoubtedly will be a major campaign issue once again, and our representatives should use the high public interest to fight for the hundreds of thousands of young people whose lives, deeds and achievements have proven that they deserve to be recognized as Americans, with all the rights and protections that come with that recognition.

This editorial first appeared in Monday;s edition of the Toledo Blade.

(6) entries


Send them all home. One of these “dreamers” was responsible for the senseless, vicious murder of Etta Nugent in Houston last week.


These activist judges need to be removed. They are only making these rulings to oppose President Trump. Never before has an executive order been forced to remain in place by a do called judge. All illegals need to be deported. The wall needs to be built ASAP, and they apply for citizenship like the rest.


The Judges are doing their job. They do not have to vow loyalty to trump like Barr and the rest of his cabinet. But in typical trump fashion when someone doesn’t agree with him, he starts calling them names like “activist judges.” So why didn’t trump make this an issue when Republicans controlled the house and senate? Because he was too busy protecting Russia. He’s taking no action to stop interference from them in 2020 like the good comrade he his.




This entire problem occurs because Obama refused to enforce existing law. Because he was unable to get Congress to act, made up his own law. DACA was never officially made law. This is what happens when both the Executive Branch and Courts make up new law. Just follow the US constitution.


We must change ridiculous amnesty laws
I have no issues with dreamers who haven’t broke the law and aren’t on welfare to become citizens

But the illegal crossings have to stop. Illegals have killed more innocent Americans than the gun violence the facts and media love to note but they don’t publish this fact removing this factor from the statistics

Drugs coming across the borders have killed thousands. Criminals are coming across although the facts deny this and other dem cult media reports

They will drive down wages for poorest of our citizens especially Black Americans

Diseases are on the upswing from Central American carriers. Rapes and women abuse are part of this too

The dems won’t do anything because they wage on future votes so American citizens must suffer

Sign the guestbook.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.